Opening a Stocks and Shares ISA is genuinely easy. Choosing what goes inside it, and then leaving it alone for long enough to matter, is where most people come unstuck. The mistakes below are rarely dramatic. They tend to be small, sensible-sounding decisions — following a tip, buying the fund at the top of the bestseller list, checking the balance every morning — that quietly shave money off your returns over years. Here is what to watch for.

Chasing whatever did well last year

Every platform publishes its best-performing funds, and it is tempting to read that list as a shortlist. It is not one.

A fund that has just had a spectacular run has usually done so because whatever it holds — a region, a sector, a handful of very large companies — has been in favour. Favour rotates. Buying after a strong year often means buying when valuations are fullest and much of the easy gain has already been made.

This does not mean past performance tells you nothing. It tells you about the past. Before you buy, ask three questions: what does this fund actually hold, why do I want to own those things, and what job does it do in my plan? If you cannot answer, keep looking.

Ignoring the fees

Charges feel abstract, so people skip past them. That is a mistake, because charges are one of the few things about investing you can actually control. A gap of one percentage point a year on a £20,000 pot is £200 — and it is £200 that never gets the chance to compound.

The costs that add up

• Platform fee. What your provider charges to hold the account. Some charge a percentage of your balance, others a flat fee. Percentage fees bite harder on large pots; flat fees often suit them better.
• The fund's ongoing charge. The annual cost of the fund itself. Index funds are usually cheaper than actively managed ones, and the difference compounds.
• Dealing and currency costs. Buying, selling, or holding funds priced in dollars can each cost something.
• Exit and transfer fees. Less common than they once were, but worth checking before you commit.

Add them up rather than looking at one headline rate. Then decide whether the extra cost buys you something you actually value.

Treating the ISA like a shopping list

New investors often buy a dozen individual shares they like the sound of, or eight funds they have read about, and assume the number of holdings is the same thing as being diversified. It is not.

Owning fifteen companies that all sell similar things in the same country is one bet, not fifteen. Owning a global fund and a US fund sounds broader than it is, because the global fund already holds those American companies — you have simply doubled up on them.

Diversification is about owning different things, not many things. For most people starting out, a single low-cost global index fund does more useful work than a hand-picked collection of shares. Add to it later if you have a reason to.

Forgetting that an ISA is a wrapper, not an investment

An ISA is a tax wrapper. It is the box, not the contents. That distinction catches people out in several ways.

The most common is contributing money and assuming it is now invested. It may still be sitting as cash inside the account until you choose a fund and place the order. Check your statement or dashboard; if your money is in "cash" rather than a fund, it is doing nothing.

The second is mixing up cash ISAs and Stocks and Shares ISAs. They are different products with different risks, and a Stocks and Shares ISA can fall in value.

Third, transfers. You can move an ISA from one provider to another without losing its tax advantages, but do it as a formal transfer rather than withdrawing the money and paying it back in. If you withdraw and replace, it can count against your allowance unless your provider offers a flexible ISA — check before you act.

Reacting to every headline

Markets fall. Headlines shout about it. If your habit is to check the balance daily, the temptation to sell in a dip and wait for things to calm down is strong — and it is how many investors end up locking in a loss and missing the recovery.

The gap between what funds return and what investors actually earn is well documented, and behaviour is a large part of the reason.

A simple portfolio held for twenty years usually beats a clever one held for twenty days at a time.

Two things help. Set up a monthly contribution so buying happens without you deciding each time. And write down, in one sentence, why you own each fund. When you are tempted to sell, read your own note.

Getting the basics in the wrong order

Before the investing decisions come a few practical ones.

• Do not invest money you will need soon. If you are buying a house next year or facing an uncertain job situation, shares are the wrong home for that money. A common rule of thumb is a horizon of at least five years, ideally longer.
• Build a cash buffer first. A few months of expenses in an easy-access account means a surprise bill does not force you to sell investments at a bad moment.
• Do not rush the deadline. The annual ISA allowance resets each tax year, and you can put in up to the limit — check the current figure on GOV.UK for the year you are in. Plenty of people pile in during March after months of doing nothing. Spreading contributions across the year is calmer and avoids one unlucky entry point.
• Clear expensive debt first. Paying off a credit card charging a high rate is a guaranteed return that no fund can promise.

A checklist before you press buy

1. You know what the fund holds, roughly.
2. You know the total cost — platform plus fund.
3. You know why this holding is in your plan.
4. You can leave the money alone for at least five years.
5. You have a cash buffer elsewhere.
6. You have set up a regular contribution rather than relying on willpower.

Get those six things right and you will avoid most of the damage new investors do to themselves. The rest is patience, which no platform can sell you.

This is general information, not personal advice. If your circumstances are complicated — you are close to retirement, have significant debts, or are unsure how tax applies to you — speak to a regulated financial adviser.

Photo: Goumbik / Pixabay